We research the details so you can choose with a little more clarity. We have not hands-on tested these products. Our approach · How shopping links work
Some purchases earn their place in the cupboard through the smallest daily ritual. A toy comes out, your Frenchie takes an interest, and there is a little something to explore while you stay close by. Toppl and KONG Classic approach that moment with different shapes. We would begin with the opening, the size and the cleanup—ordinary details that help you decide which deserves a place in your home.
WHERE WE WOULD BEGIN
Choose for your everyday.
Toppl is the one to investigate if its open cup appeals to you for filling and checking the inside. KONG Classic is worth considering if you prefer its narrower-opening shape and the Classic rubber option. Neither is a default Frenchie size or a promise of a particular playtime. Choose for your dog’s mouth, chewing style and comfortable use.
Begin with the opening.
For a short-muzzled dog, a product’s outside dimensions tell only part of the story. How does the mouth meet the opening? Can the dog reach inside without repeatedly pressing its face into an awkward position? Is the toy easy to steady, or does every attempt send it scooting away?
Toppl’s open cup makes those questions especially interesting. It is a plausible reason to try the shape, not proof that every Frenchie will find it easier. The first few supervised sessions should tell you about your own dog—not about how long someone else’s dog stayed busy.
Let enjoyment set the pace.
A toy that takes longer is not automatically a better toy. There is a difference between a dog happily working something out and a dog giving up or turning to destructive chewing. Stay nearby, notice the difference and put the toy away if the interaction becomes uncomfortable.
Start with food already appropriate for your dog and account for it within the routine you follow. This comparison is about the products; it is not a feeding plan. There is no need to buy a cupboard full of extras to learn whether a particular shape suits your Frenchie.
The sink gets a vote, too.
Picture the toy after the interesting part is over. You will want to see what is left inside, clean it according to the maker’s directions and inspect it before the next use. West Paw lists top-rack dishwasher care for Toppl. For either toy, make cleanup part of the purchase decision rather than a surprise that arrives with the first wash.
If you compare them at home, make a small note about filling, access and cleanup. Keep your expectations specific. “Easy to inspect inside” is useful. “Perfect for every Frenchie” is a promise no shape can make.
The details: West Paw Toppl care and intended use · KONG Classic instructions
One toy can be enough to begin.
Toppl can also be paired in compatible sizes: Small with Large, or Large with XL. That is an optional variation involving a second piece, not something you need in order to begin. There is value in learning how your dog uses one suitable toy before deciding whether more complexity would actually add anything.
Our preference is to keep the first choice simple and the observation generous. Watch your dog, check the toy, and leave room to change your mind. The best addition to the cupboard is one that makes sense in the life you already share.
The details: Toppl size pairing
The details, side by side.
Scroll across to see both products.
| What matters | West Paw Toppl | KONG Classic |
|---|---|---|
| Shape to consider | Open cup with interior ridges | Rounded rubber body with a narrower opening |
| Reference size only | Large: 3.5 × 4 × 3.5 in; ¾ cup | Medium: 2.25 × 2.25 × 3.5 in |
| Manufacturer’s intended chew use | Moderate chewers | Average chewers |
| Care and supervision | Top-rack dishwasher; supervise use | Follow cleaning directions; supervise use |
THE FITTING ROOM
A useful size starts with your dog, not the product name.
Large Toppl and Medium KONG are reference variants in this comparison, not equivalent sizes and not breed recommendations.
Use the exact size guide
Consider the maker’s mouth-size and chewing guidance. Resolve KONG’s conflicting Medium weight guidance with the manufacturer before choosing.
Check access during supervised use
Notice how your dog reaches the opening and whether the toy can be used comfortably. Stop if there is distress, unsafe chewing or damage.
Write down what works
Record the exact model and size, then note access, cleaning effort and the condition after each early session.
Toppl size and use guidance · KONG Classic · KONG size-selection guidance
Keep your measurements togetherA place on your shortlist.
West Paw · For an open-cup approach
Toppl
The open shape makes access and cleanup useful questions to investigate. It gives you a different starting point from a toy with a smaller entry opening.
Easy access may also mean easier emptying. Check chewing behavior and condition throughout use; it is not an indestructible toy.
Explore at ChewyRetailer link. We do not earn a commission from this link. Check the selected size, model, price and availability with the seller.
KONG · For the familiar rubber shape
Classic
Its shape offers a different food-access puzzle to compare with Toppl. The useful choice is the one your individual dog can engage with comfortably.
KONG’s published Medium weight guidance differs between pages. Confirm the current size with the manufacturer rather than choosing Medium because it appears in this table.
Explore at ChewyRetailer link. We do not earn a commission from this link. Check the selected size, model, price and availability with the seller.
A little care before you choose.
- These observations are research-based; we have not performed hands-on testing.
- Inspect before and during use. Follow the manufacturer’s directions and remove damaged toys.
- A toy is not a treatment for anxiety, dental problems or a medical condition.
A LITTLE NOTE TO KEEP
All their little measurements.
One lovely place to keep them.
Make a quiet moment of it. Our free, fillable worksheet keeps your Frenchie’s measurements, fitting notes and car-ramp checks together for the next good find.
Get the measurement worksheet Read the measuring guideSources & editorial notes
Last checked October 3, 2026. Our suggestions are editorial interpretations of the sources below, not results from hands-on testing.
- West Paw Toppl specifications
- KONG Classic specifications
- KONG sizing guide: confirm conflicting Medium guidance
- Chewy Toppl listing: Tangerine Large
- Chewy KONG Classic listing: Medium
Spotted a change? Let us know.